Home
welcome to the Caribbean Court of Justice
about the caribbean court of justice
about the regional judicial anmd legal services commission
jjudges of the caribbean court of justice
court administration
the court registry
the court schedule
attorneys-at-law
the court library of the caribbean court of justice
the CCJ code of ethics
related rules
audio
judgments
related papers and addresses
the board of trustees of the caribbean court of justice
about the caribbean region and CARICOM
the revised treaty of chaguaramas
news of the caribbean court of justice
media releases from the CCJ
Events
Inauguration of the CCJ
Photos
contact the caribbean court of justice
Tender Notices
career at the caribbean court of justice
search the caribbean court of justice

Judgments

 

DATE DESCRIPTION
16 AUG 2010

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No CV 1 of 2010 between FRANK ERROL GIBSON APPELLANT and THE ATTORNEY GENERAL RESPONDENT
[2010] CCJ 3 (AJ)

JUDGMENT
of The President and Justices Nelson, Saunders, Bernard, and Wit

Delivered jointly by
The Honourable Mr Justice Adrian Saunders
and The Honourable Mr Justice Jacob Wit

JUDGMENT

Download the pdf - 88kb

31 MAR 2010

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co- Operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No. CV 14 of 2007 between JASSODA RAMKISHUN APPELLANT and CONRAD ASHFORD FUNG-KEE-FUNG, DOREEN ELIZABETH DEANE AND LEILA GLENDON RESPONDENTS
[2010 ] CCJ 2 (AJ)

JUDGMENT
of The Right Honourable Mr. Justice de la Bastide, President and The Honourable Justices Pollard, Bernard and Wit

Delivered by
The Honourable Mr. Justice Wit

and JUDGMENT
of The Honourable Mr. Justice Nelson

JUDGMENT

Download the pdf - 360kb

SUMMARY
of The Right Honourable Mr. Justice de la Bastide, President and The Honourable Justices Pollard, Bernard and Wit

Download the pdf - 63kb

and SUMMARY
of The Honourable Mr. Justice Nelson

Download the pdf - 44kb

29 MAR 2010

Original Jurisdiction CCJ Application No. OA 2 of 2009 between TRINIDAD CEMENT LIMITED, TCL GUYANA INCORPORATED APPLICANTS AND THE STATE OF THE CO-OPERATIVE REPUBLIC OF GUYANA RESPONDENTS
[2009] CCJ 1 (OJ)

THE COURT,
composed of M de la Bastide, R Nelson, A Saunders, J Wit and D Hayton, Judges

JUDGMENT

Download the pdf - 121kb

SUMMARY

Download the pdf - 58kb

11 FEB 2010

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No. CR 2 of 2009 between JEFFREY ADOLPHUS GITTENS, APPELLANT AND THE QUEEN, RESPONDENT
[2010] CCJ 1 (AJ)

JUDGMENT
of
The President and Justices Nelson, Pollard, Saunders, Bernard, Wit and Hayton

Delivered jointly by
The Right Honourable Mr Justice Michael de la Bastide
and The Honourable Mme Justice Bernard

JUDGMENT

Download the pdf - 154kb

04 DEC 2009

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No. CV 1 of 2009 between VERNON O'CONNELL HOPE, APPELLANT AND SHAKA WAYNE RODNEY, PORTFOLIO INVESTMENTS LTD, RESPONDENTS
[2009] CCJ 12 (AJ)

JUDGMENT
of
The President and Justices Pollard, Saunders, Bernard and Hayton

Delivered jointly by
The Right Honourable Mr Justice Michael de la Bastide
and The Honourable Mr Justice Saunders

JUDGMENT

Download the pdf - 202kb

SUMMARY

Download the pdf - 114kb

02 DEC 2009

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No CR 2 of 2009 between JEFFREY ADOLPHUS GITTENS APPELLANT AND THE QUEEN RESPONDENT

DECISION
Delivered orally by
The President, The Right Honourable Mr Justice Michael de la Bastide

ORAL DECISION

Download the pdf - 48kb

14 OCT 2009

Original Jurisdiction CCJ Application No. OA 2 of 2009 between TRINIDAD CEMENT LIMITED, TCL GUYANA INCORPORATED CLAIMANTS AND THE STATE OF THE CO-OPERATIVE REPUBLIC OF GUYANA DEFENDENTS
[2009] CCJ (OJ)

THE COURT,
composed of R Nelson, A Saunders, J Wit and D Hayton, Judges

JUDGMENT

Download the pdf - 69kb

08 OCT 2009

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co- Operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No. CV 13 of 2007 between ELIZABETH ROSS APPELLANT and COREEN SINCLAIR RESPONDENT
[2009 ] CCJ 11 (AJ)

JUDGMENT
of The President and Justices Pollard, Saunders, Bernard and Hayton

Delivered jointly by
The President and The Honourable Mr. Justice Adrian Saunders

JUDGMENT

Download the pdf - 201kb

Summary

Download the pdf - 101kb

20 AUG 2009

Original Jurisdiction CCJ Application No. OA 2 of 2009
between TRINIDAD CEMENT LIMITED, TCL GUYANA INCORPORATED CLAIMANT and THE CO-OPERATIVE REPUBLIC OF GUYANA DEFENDANT
ADVANCE COPY
[2009] CCJ 5 (OJ)

THE COURT,
composed of M de la Bastide, President and R Nelson, A Saunders, J Wit and D Hayton, Judges

JUDGMENT

Download the pdf - 136kb

Summary

Download the pdf - 60kb

10 AUG 2009

Original Jurisdiction CCJ Application No. OA 1 of 2009
between TRINIDAD CEMENT LIMITED CLAIMANT
and THE CARIBBEAN COMMUNITY DEFENDANT
ADVANCE COPY
[2009] CCJ 4 (OJ)

THE COURT,
composed of M de la Bastide, President and R Nelson, A Saunders, D Bernard and J Wit, Judges

Issues JUDGMENT

Download the pdf - 415kb

Summary

Download the pdf - 22kb

10 AUG 2009

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-Operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Civil Appeal No. CV 4 of 2008 between L.O.P. INVESTMENTS LIMITED APPELLANT
and DEMERARA BANK LIMITED, GARRETT WARD, RAMON GASKIN RESPONDENTS
ADVANCE COPY
[2009] CCJ 10 (AJ)

JUDGMENT
of The Court

Delivered by
The Honourable Mr Justice David Hayton

Download the pdf - 186kb

Summary

Download the pdf - 58kb

30 JUNE 2009

Appeal from The Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No. CR 1 of 2008 between JULIAN OSCAR FRANCIS APPELLANT and THE QUEEN RESPONDENT
[2009] CCJ 9 (AJ)

JUDGMENT
of the President and Justices Nelson, Bernard and Hayton

Delivered by the President
The Right Honourable Mr. Justice Michael de la Bastide

and JUDGMENT
of the Honourable Mr. Justice Adrian Saunders

Download the pdf - 239kb

30 JUNE 2009

Appeal From The Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No. CV 12 of 2007 between LACKRAM BISNAUTH, deceased substituted by his Executor EDWARD JONATHAN APPELLANT and RAMANAND SHEWPRASHAD and RAJWATTIE BISNAUTH RESPONDENTS
[2009] CCJ 8 (AJ)

JUDGMENT
of Justices Nelson, Pollard, Bernard and Hayton

Delivered jointly by
The Honourable Mr Justice Duke Pollard and Mme Justice Desiree Bernard

and JUDGMENT
of The Honourable Mr Justice Jacob Wit

Download the pdf - 202kb

27 MAY 2009

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No. AL 5 of 2008 between RAMNARINE SOMRAH APPLICANT and THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF GUYANA, THE POLICE SERVICE COMMISSION RESPONDENTS
[2009] CCJ 5 (AJ)

JUDGMENT of
The Honourable Justices Nelson, Pollard, Saunders, Hayton and Wit
 
Delivered by
The Honourable Mr Justice Nelson

Download the pdf - 38kb

22 MAY 2009

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No. CV 1 of 2009 between VERNON O’CONNELL HOPE APPELLANT and SHAKA WAYNE RODNEY 1ST RESPONDENT, PORTOFOLIO INVESTMENTS LIMITED 2nd RESPONDENT
[2009] CCJ 7 (AJ)

JUDGMENT of
Mr Justice de la Bastide, President and the Honourables Mr Justice Saunders, JCCJ, Mme Justice Bernard, JCCJ

Delivered orally by the President
The Right Honourable Mr Justice Michael de la Bastide

Download the pdf - 139kb

01 MAY 2009

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No. AL 2 of 2008 between L.O.P.  Investments Limited APPLICANT and Demerara Bank Limited, Garrett Ward, Ramon Gaskin RESPONDENTS
[2009] CCJ 4 (AJ)

JUDGMENT of the Court

Download the pdf - 38kb

15 APR 2009

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No. CV3 of 2008 between Subhas Ramdeo APPLICANT and Heralall RESPONDENT.
[2009] CCJ 3 (AJ)

JUDGMENT of
The Honourable Justices Nelson, Pollard, Saunders, Bernard and Hayton
 
Delivered by
The Honourable Mr Justice David Hayton

Download the pdf - 131kb

03 APR 2009

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No. CR 1 of 2009 between Clyde Anderson Grazette APPLICANT and The Queen RESPONDENT
[2009] CCJ 2 (AJ)

JUDGMENT of the Court

Download the pdf - 50kb

 

03 APR 2009

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No. CV 2 of 2008 between Winton Campbell APPLICANT and The Attorney General RESPONDENT
[2009] CCJ 1 (AJ)

JUDGMENT of the Court

Download the pdf - 198kb

02 MAR 2009

In the Caribbean Court of Justice, Original Jurisdiction, CCJ Application No AR 2 of 2008 between Doreen Johnson APPLICANT and Caribbean Centre for Development Administration RESPONDENT
[2009] CCJ 3 (OJ)

JUDGMENT of the Court

Download the pdf - 213kb

09 FEB 2009

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Application No AL 7 of 2008 between Chamanlall Mukhtiyar and Dhandai Mukhtiyar APPELLANTS and

  1. Poonardai Sukhu
  2. Hardeo Balgobin
  3. Rajendra Balgobin and
  4. Rohan Balgobin

RESPONDENTS

[2009] CCJ 6 (AJ)

JUDGMENT
Delivered orally by the President
The Right Honourable Mr. Justice Michael de la Bastide

Download the pdf - 23kb

05 FEB 2009

In the Caribbean Court of Justice, Original Jurisdiction, CCJ Application No AR 3 of 2008 between Trinidad Cement Limited APPLICANT and The Caribbean Community RESPONDENT
[2009] CCJ 2 (OJ)

JUDGMENT of the Court

Download the pdf - 61kb

15 JAN 2009

In the Caribbean Court of Justice CCJ Application No AR 1 of 2008 between Trinidad Cement Limited & TCL Guyana Incorporated APPLICANT and The State of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana RESPONDENTS

JUDGMENT of the Court

Download the pdf - 290kb

17 DEC 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No CV 8 of 2007 between David Lachana A/C Lachana, Sadonel Devi Lachana APPELLANT and Cooblal Arjune, Tara Ajune RESPONDENTS

JUDGMENT
Of Justices Nelson, Pollard, Bernard, Wit and Hayton

Delivered by
The Honourable Mr. Justice Jacob Wit

Download the pdf - 98kb

16 DEC 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No CV 4 of 2007 between John Sealey APPELLANT and The Attorney General of Guyana and The Police Service Commission RESPONDENTS

JUDGMENT
Of The President and Justices Nelson, Pollard, Wit and Hayton

Delivered jointly by
The Honourable Mr. Justice Rolston Nelson
and The Honourable Mr. Justice David Hayton

Download the pdf - 150kb

16 DEC 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No CV 3 of 2007 between Stephen Edwards APPELLANT and The Attorney General of Guyana and The Police Service Commission RESPONDENTS

JUDGMENT
Of The President and Justices Nelson, Wit and Hayton

Delivered jointly by
The Honourable Mr. Justice Rolston Nelson
and The Honourable Mr. Justice David Hayton

and JUDGMENT
Of The Honourable Mr. Justice Pollard

Download the pdf - 237kb

24 NOV 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No. CV 9 of 2007 between Yolande Reid APPLICANT and Jerome Reid RESPONDENTS.
[2006] CCJ 4 (AJ).

Judgment of The President and Justices Saunders, Bernard, Wit and Hayton.

Delivered by
The Honourable Mr. Justice Adrian Saunders

Download the pdf - 63kb

07 NOV 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Application No AL 3 of 2008 between Chamanlall Mukhtiyar and Dhandai Mukhtiyar APPELLANTS and

  1. Poonardai Sukhu
  2. Hardeo Balgobin
  3. Rajendra Balgobin and
  4. Rohan Balgobin

RESPONDENTS

JUDGMENT
Delivered orally by the President
The Right Honourable Mr. Justice Michael de la Bastide

Download the pdf - 73kb

18 SEP 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No CV 5 of 2007 between Vibert Gibson APPELLANT  and The Attorney General of Guyana RESPONDENT

Delivered by
The President and Justices Saunders and Bernard.

Download the pdf - 16kb

22 JUL 2008

Application for Special Leave (Original Jurisdiction) CCJ Application No. AR 1 of 2008 between Trinidad Cement Limited-TCL Guyana Incorporated APPLICANTS and The Co-operative Republic of Guyana RESPONDENT
[2008] CCJ 1 (OJ)

JUDGMENT of the Court

Download the pdf - 28kb

22 JUL 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No CV 3 of 2006 between Harrinauth  Ramdass APPELLANT  and

  1. Salim Jairam, substituted for Loki
    pursuant to order of court dated 26th february 2008
  2. Amina Mohamed, substituted for Ali Mohamed
    pursuant to order of court dated 21st february 1996
  3. Asaf Ali Mohammed the administrator of the
    estate of Ali Mohamed by Letters of Administration
    granted on the 8th day of September 1994, No 141 of 1994
  4. The Registrar of deeds of the High Court of the Supreme Court
    RESPONDENTS [2008] CCJ 6 (AJ)

JUDGMENT Of The Court

Delivered by The Honourable Mme. Justice D. Bernard

Download the pdf - 76KB

SUMMARY

Download the pdf - 43kb

15 JUL 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana Ccj Appeal No CV 1 of 2007 between Toolsie Persaud Limited APPELLANT And
1.         Andrew James Investments Limited               
2.         Shivlochnie Singh (by order of court)
3.         The Attorney General of Guyana
RESPONDENTS. [2008] CCJ 5 (AJ)

JOINT JUDGMENT Of The Court

Delivered by
The President, the Right Honourable Mr Justice Michael de la Bastide and The Honourable Mr Justice David Hayton

download the pdf - 81kb

Summary

download the pdf - 18kb

16 MAY 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No CV 13 of 2007 between Elizabeth Ross APPLICANT and Coreen Sinclair RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT Of
the President and Justices Nelson, Saunders, Bernard, Wit.

Delivered by the President of the Court, The Rt. Hon. Mr. Justice M. de la Bastide

download the pdf - 35kb

26 MAR 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No CV 10 of 2007 between Mohammed Yasseen APPLICANT and The Attorney General of Guyana RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT
Of the President and Justices Saunders and Bernard.

Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice Saunders

download the pdf - 23kb

11 MAR 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No CV 7 of 2007 between Wesley Emptage APPLICANT and The Attorney General of Guyana RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT
Of the President and Justices Saunders and Bernard.

Delivered by the President of the Court, The Rt. Hon. Mr. Justice M. de la Bastide

download the pdf - 10kb

11 MAR 2008

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No CV 6 of 2007 between Euland Hendy APPLICANT and The Commissioner of Police, The Attorney General of Guyana RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT
Of the President and Justices Saunders and Bernard.

Delivered by the President of the Court, The Rt. Hon. Mr. Justice M. de la Bastide

download the pdf - 25kb

27 JUN 2007

Appeal From The Court Of Appeal Of The Co-Operative Republic Of Guyana CCJ Application No AL 7 of 2006 between Dwarka Nauth APPLICANT And The Attorney General of Guyana, the Public Service Commission, the Regional Executive Officer, the Minister of Finance RESPONDENTS. [2007] CCJ 4 (AJ)

JUDGMENT
Of the President and Justices Nelson and Bernard.

Delivered by The Honourable Mme. Justice D. Bernard

download the pdf - 39kb

04 JUN 2007

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No. CR 1 of 2006 between The Queen APPLICANT and Mitchell Ken O'Neal Lewis RESPONDENT. [2007] CCJ 3 (AJ)

JUDGMENT
Of the President and Justices Nelson, Saunders, Bernard, Wit and Hayton.

Delivered by the President
The Right Honourable Mr Justice Michael de la Bastide

and JUDGMENT
Of the Honourable Mr. Justice Pollard

download the pdf - 174kb

04 APR 2007

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No CR 3 of 2006 between Vaughn Thomas APPLICANT and The State RESPONDENT

Delivered by the President of the Court, The Rt. Hon. Mr. Justice M. de la Bastide

download the pdf - 70kb

25 Jan 2007

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Appeal No CV 2 of 2006 between Gladston Watson APPLICANT  and Rosedale Fernandes RESPONDENT.

Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice A. Saunders and
The Honourable Mr. Justice D. Hayton

download the pdf - 70kb

04 Dec 2006

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No. AL 6 of 2006 between Tyrone daCosta Cadogan APPLICANT and The Queen RESPONDENTS.
[2006] CCJ 4 (AJ).

Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice D. Hayton

download the pdf - 38kb

08 Nov 2006

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No. CV 2 of 2005 BB Civil Appeal No. 29 of 2004 between The Attorney General Superintendent of Prisons Chief Marshal APPLICANT and Jeffrey Joseph Lennox Ricardo Boyce RESPONDENTS.

Delivered by the President of the Court, The Rt. Hon. Mr. Justice M. de la Bastide and the Hon. Mr. Justice A. Saunders
download the pdf - 281kb (Advance Copy)

Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice R. Nelson
download the pdf - 79kb (Advance Copy)

Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice D. Pollard
download the pdf - 217kb (Advance Copy)

Delivered by The Honourable Mme.. Justice D. Bernard
download the pdf - 83kb (Advance Copy)

Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice J. Wit
download the pdf - 134kb (Advance Copy)

Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice D. Hayton
download the pdf - 36kb (Advance Copy)

Summaries

Overall Summary
download the pdf - 19kb

Summary of the Judgment delivered by the President of the Court, The Rt. Hon. Mr. Justice M. de la Bastide and the Hon. Mr. Justice A. Saunders
download the pdf - 18kb

Summary of the Judgment Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice R. Nelson
download the pdf - 24kb

Summary of the Judgment Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice D. Pollard
download the pdf - 20kb

Summary of the Judgment Delivered by The Honourable Mme. Justice D. Bernard
download the pdf - 21kb

Summary of the Judgment Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice J. Wit
download the pdf - 24kb

Summary of the Judgment Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice D. Hayton
download the pdf - 14kb

12 May 2006

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of the C0-operative Republic of Guyana CCJ Application No. 1 of 2006 GY Civil Appeal No. 27 of 2003. In the Matter of an Application by Brent Griffith in terms of Articles 142 and 146 of the Constitution between Brent Griffith APPLICANT and Guyana Revenue Authority Attorney General of Guyana RESPONDENTS

Delivered by The Honourable Mr. Justice R. Nelson

download the pdf - 64kb

16 Mar 2006

Appeal from the Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Appeal No. CV 1 of 2005 BB Civil Appeal No. 18 of 2000 between Barbados Rediffusion Service Limited APPLICANT and Asha Mirchandani Ram Mirchandani McDonald Farms Ltd. RESPONDENTS

Delivered by the President of the Court, The Rt. Hon. Mr. Justice M. de la Bastide

download the pdf - 113kb

26 Oct 2005

Application for Special Leave to Appeal from The Court of Appeal of Barbados CCJ Application No. AL 1 of 2005 BB Civil Appeal No. 18 of 2000  between Barbados Rediffusion Service Limited APPLICANT And Asha Mirchandani Ram Mirchandani McDonald Farms LTD. RESPONDENTS

Delivered by the President of the Court, The Rt. Hon. Mr. Justice M. de la Bastide

download the pdf - 71kb

Updated by the Court Protocol & Information Division 2006; Copyright 2003, Caribbean Court of Justice. All Rights Reserved. info@caribbeancourtofjustice.org; webmaster@caribbeancourtofjustice.org
134 Henry Street, Port of Spain, Republic of Trinidad and Tobago.
Grenada Antigua & Barbuda Bahamas Barbados Belize Dominica Guyana Montserrat St. Kitts & Nevis St. Lucia St. Vincent & The Grendines Suriname Trinidad & Tobago